NEWS AND ANNOUNCEMENTS

The success of the National Civics Initiative has led Judges from within the Sixth Circuit being asked to teach other federal judges how best to educate students and adults about civics and the workings of the federal courts and three branches of government. In April 2018, and again in July 2018, Judge Michael Newman (from the Southern District of Ohio), Rebecca Fanning (from the Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts), Judge Shaniek Maynard (from the Southern District of Florida), and Judge Kristen Mix (from the District of Colorado) spoke together at the national Magistrate Judges Workshops in New Orleans and Denver.

On July 1, 2020, Senior Judge Curtis L. Collier participated in a book reading recording at the Bessie Smith Cultural Center in Chattanooga for the Center’s new series titled “Bessie’s Front Porch.” The series will be posted on the Center’s Facebook page to reach children during the COVID-19 pandemic. Judge Collier read Martin’s Big Words: The Life of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., written by Doreen Rappaport and illustrated by Bryan Collier (no relation).”

Earlier this week, the United States District Court for the Southern District of Ohio held its first-ever Teachers’ Institute civics education program in the Dayton seat of court. Teachers from throughout the Dayton community spent two days learning about criminal cases (on Day 1) and civil cases (on Day 2).  

In addition to hearing from multiple federal judges and participating in a mock trial with the assistance of law firm counsel, the teachers heard from representatives of the United States Attorney’s Office, the Federal Public Defender’s Office, Pretrial Services and Probation. United States Marshall Michael Black and Federal Public Defender Joe Medici also spoke to the teachers.  

The Dayton judges are grateful to our Chief Judge, the Hon. Algenon Marbley, who fully and enthusiastically supported this effort. The judges also thank Rebecca Fanning from the Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts for her assistance in planning this civics event.

Next month, the Dayton judges will host the two-day Dayton Students’ Justice Institute, a civics education seminar for high school students - the first of its kind in the Dayton federal courthouse. 

The Dayton judges plan to hold both the Teachers‘ Institute and the Students’ Justice Institute every summer going forward.

Photo: Standing with Dayton teachers are (left to right) United States Magistrate Judge Caroline Gentry, United States District Judge Michael Newman, and United States Magistrate Judge Peter Silvain. 

On June 26, 2024, Judge Michael Newman and Magistrate Judge Caroline Gentry met with law student externs - from the U.S. District Court and from Legal Aid of Western Ohio - as part of the Southern District of Ohio’s continuing civics education outreach efforts.

On July 8 and 9, 2024, the United States District Court for the Southern District of Ohio held, in the Dayton seat of court, its first-ever civics court camp for high school students - what the court calls the “Dayton Student Justice Institute.”

More than 40 high school students from throughout the Dayton region heard from United States District Judges and United States Magistrate Judges; career and term federal law clerks; Richard Nagel, the Clerk of Court; Joseph Medici, the Federal Public Defender; Assistant U.S. Attorneys; Assistant Federal Public Defenders; and representatives from U.S. Pretrial Services and U.S. Probation.

Day 1 of the Justice Institute was focused on criminal law including sentencing; Day 2 was focused on civil law including immigration. On Day 2, the high school students heard from University of Dayton School of Law (“UDSL”) professor Ericka Curran, who explained immigration law, and a representative from the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services. UDSL Associate Dean Chris Roederer also explained the First Amendment to the high school students.

The students witnessed a naturalization ceremony for 10 new citizens on Day 2 and concluded the Justice Institute with a moot court on a First Amendment school law issue.

The Court is grateful to Magistrate Judge Peter Silvain for planning the Justice Institute along with United States District Judge Michael Newman and United States Magistrate Judge Caroline Gentry.

Dayton-area high school students participating in the Dayton Federal Court’s inaugural Justice Institute pose with Judge Newman, Judge Silvain, Judge Gentry, Clerk Nagel, Professor Curran, and Judge Silvain’s law clerks.

The Civics & Service Committee continues its three major projects: the Naturalization Civics Challenge, the Clerkship Chats, and the Speech Bank. In this edition of The Bench Press, we focus on the Naturalization Civics Challenge.

As a reminder, in the Naturalization Civics Challenge, high-school students take the naturalization civics test. If they score at least 90%, we award them an “Excellent Citizen” certificate and invite them to attend a federal-court naturalization ceremony in their home judicial district before a federal judge. 

We’ve now completed the first year of the Naturalization Civics Challenge and have embarked on the second. We think it’s been a great success! 

Here’s what one teacher whose class participated in the Challenge and attended a naturalization ceremony in the Middle District of Georgia had to say:

I took 17 of our students to a Naturalization Ceremony in Columbus, Ga, on September 5, 2024. We got to tour the judge’s chambers prior to the ceremony and Judge Clay Land honored our students and included them in the ceremony introduction. It was a wonderful experience overall! My students were very appreciative of the opportunity and had several really great conversations about the process.

This is something I am so happy to have accessible to my school! I hope to continue to participate in the program with more students as the school year continues.

 

Thank you for everything you do for this program!

And here is a picture of Judge Beth Bloom of the Southern District of Florida, along with students and their teacher from MAST Academy in Miami, after the students attended a naturalization ceremony over which Judge Bloom presided in June 2024:

We thank all of you who have generously given your time to this project, and we look forward to your continuing support.

If you are aware of any teachers or students who are interested in participating, they can find information about the challenge at this link: https://federaljudgesassoc.org/federal-judges-association-civics-challenge/

Oakwood, Ohio – January 10, 2025: U.S. District Court Judges from the Southern District of Ohio came together to educate Oakwood City School's eighth grade and high school students about civics, the court system, and careers in law.  Led by U.S. District Judge Michael Newman, the initiative featured a naturalization ceremony and included Magistrate Judges Peter Silvain, Jr. and Caroline Gentry along with U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Guy Humphrey.

From left: Matt Salyer Oakwood High School principal, Tim Badenhop Oakwood Middle School principal, Judge Ellis Montgomery County Common Pleas Court, Judge Gentry, Dr. Neil Gupta Superintendent, Judge Silvain, Judge Newman, Judge Humphrey – Bankruptcy Court

On March 4, 2025, Holland & Knight partner Andrew Lowenstein traveled from West Palm Beach, Florida to Dayton to meet with federal judges from both Dayton and Columbus - along with bar leaders from the Dayton Bar Association and the Federal Bar Association Dayton chapter - to teach them how to do the “Civil Discourse and Difficult Decisions” civics scenario utilized by the Administrative Office of the United States Courts in Washington, D.C. Thereafter, the judges, law clerks and bar leaders engaged in a three- hour civics presentation and oral argument session by the students with high school students from the Dayton STEM School.

Federal judges Michael Newman, Caroline Gentry and Peter Silvain, Jr. pose with federal court law clerks helping to organize the civics program along with University of Dayton School of Law professor Shea Dailey, Assistant U.S. Attorney Jade Smarda, and Federal Bar Association Dayton chapter president Mike Scarpelli.

Pictured here is Dayton Bar Association President, Judge Michael Newman; United States Magistrate Judge Peter Silvain, Jr.; United States Magistrate Judge Elizabeth Deavers from Columbus, Ohio; Andrew Loewenstein; and DBA executive Director, Jennifer Otchy.

The Dayton STEM School students, federal judges, federal court law clerks and externs, and Andrew Lowenstein all pose together following the students’ oral argument and civics presentation.

On March 11, Judge Parker from the Montgomery County, Ohio Common Pleas Court, and Judge Newman from the U.S. District Court in Dayton, talked to two high school civics classes at Tippecanoe High School in Tipp City, Ohio.  The judges discussed judicial elections (Judge Parker) and appointment (Judge Newman); difficult trials; life as a lawyer and judge; and recusal.

This October and November, judges in Dayton are meeting with Dayton Public School students. Here, Magistrate Judge Michael Newman poses with students from Thurgood Marshall School.